• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
Image Map
  • Home
  • Podcast
  • About Us
    • Our Story
    • Contact
      • Blogger DIY Project Submission
      • Contact Us
      • Guest Post Submission
      • PR, Advertising and Partnerships
      • Brands and Media That We Have Worked With
      • Speaking Events
  • Frugal Living
    • All Things Frugal
    • Homemade Products Gallery
    • Garden
    • Family Life
    • Travel
      • Travel Tips & Resources
      • Travel Deals & Coupons
    • Savings
      • Find Your Store Deals
      • Freebies
      • Deals
  • DIY
  • Finance
    • All Things Finance
    • Finance Tips & Resources
      • Meeting Your Financial Goals
      • Managing Household Finances
    • Dropping Debt
    • Making Money From Home
    • Over 100 Ways to Earn Extra Income
    • Our Financial Journey
  • Recipes
    • All Recipes
    • Produce Tips
    • Breakfast Ideas
  • Printables
  • How To Blog
    • Start Here
    • Resources
    • Detailed Blog Income Reports

Turkey Cookie Pops (Made with Golden Oreo, Nutter Butter and Candy Corn)

This post may contain affiliate links. Please read our disclosure policy here.

November 11 by Cassie Leave a Comment

turkey-pops-with-oreo-nutterbutter-candycorn

What a fun treat! These are so super simple, so cute and tasty that we had to share this Thanksgiving treat hack with you! We love making themed foods for family fun, party fun, holiday fun and just because and these little pops are no exception. They are made with ingredients that most people love – Golden Oreos, Mini Nutter Butter and candy corn. Not to mention, they are also great for a centerpiece on a table, or wrap saran wrap or treat baggies around the top to give as gifts. Really there are so many options with this fun instant treat! Now please note, if you do use the royal icing, the assembly is nearly instant, but you do need to “let it dry” and set!

Here’s how to make Thanksgiving Turkey Pops

Ingredients for Thanksgiving Turkey Pops

  • 1 Package of vanilla Golden Oreo cookies
  • 1 Package of Nutter Butter mini round cookies
  • 1 Bag of candy corn
  • Pack of candy sticks found at Michaels or Walmart
  • Ribbon of your choice for decoration

Royal Icing Ingredients: (or you can use store-bought frosting!) 

  • 2 egg whites
  • 1 C powder sugar
  • 1/2 tsp cream of tartar
  • Orange, yellow & red gel food coloring

Cookie Directions:

-Separate the vanilla Oreo cookies.
-Place the half of the Oreo cookie with the filling on it on a plate.
-Add a layer of white royal icing* or store-bought frosting on top of the cookie filling.
-Place four pieces of candy corn with the white end of the candy corn on top of the royal icing.
-Place the candy stick on the icing until almost touching the candy corn.
-Put the top half of the Oreo cookie on top. (if needed add more icing to level to the top cookie).
-Allow to dry 1 hour before standing up.
-Add the mini Nutter Butter cookie on top of the Oreo cookie.
-Use the white icing as the glue to hold the mini cookie to the Oreo Cookie.
-Add a small dot of white icing as the eye on the mini nutter butter cookie.
-Place a tiny orange icing dot (eye ball) in the center of the white dot (eye).
-Add three tiny yellow  icing dots, touching each other, for the nose.
-Add a red icing for the waddle.
-Allow to dry for 5-10 hours.
-Tie a bow around the candy stick.

Icing Directions:

-Combine all ingredients in a mixing bowl mixing on medium speed for 4 minutes. (except your food coloring)
-If icing is  not stiff enough add 1/4 C powder sugar.
– Spoon the icing into a bowl (#1).  Take out 4 TBSP of icing add several drops of orange gel food coloring.  Mix well!
– Spoon the icing into a bowl (#2).  Take out 4 TBSP of icing add several drops of yellow gel food coloring.  Mix well!
-Add several drops of red  gel food coloring in a bowl  (#3) of 4 TBSP of  icing.  Stir well to mix the color.
-Keep the rest of the icing as white.
-Spoon the different colors of the icing into Individual  pastry bags with a #5 tips.
-Twist the open end of the pastry bag to  force the icing to the tip.

That’s it!

Turkey-pops-oreo-nutter-butter

Here’s a printable recipe, just click on the “print” button below.

Turkey Cookie Pops (Made with Golden Oreo, Nutter Butter and Candy Corn)
Print
Recipe type: Dessert
Cuisine: American
Author: Cassie from The Thrifty Couple
Prep time: 15 mins
Cook time: 5 hours
Total time: 5 hours 15 mins
Serves: 24
This is a fun treat for everyone to enjoy with all of the classic favorites!
Ingredients
Ingredients for Thanksgiving Turkey Pops
  • 1 Package of vanilla Golden Oreo cookies
  • 1 Package of Nutter Butter mini round cookies
  • 1 Bag of candy corn
  • Pack of candy sticks found at Michaels or Walmart
  • Ribbon of your choice for decoration
Royal Icing Ingredients: (or you can use store-bought frosting!)
  • 2 egg whites
  • 1 C powder sugar
  • ½ tsp cream of tartar
  • Orange, yellow & red gel food coloring
Instructions
Cookie Directions:
  1. -Separate the vanilla Oreo cookies.
  2. -Place the half of the Oreo cookie with the filling on it on a plate.
  3. -Add a layer of white royal icing* or store-bought frosting on top of the cookie filling.
  4. -Place four pieces of candy corn with the white end of the candy corn on top of the royal icing.
  5. -Place the candy stick on the icing until almost touching the candy corn.
  6. -Put the top half of the Oreo cookie on top. (if needed add more icing to level to the top cookie).
  7. -Allow to dry 1 hour before standing up.
  8. -Add the mini Nutter Butter cookie on top of the Oreo cookie.
  9. -Use the white icing as the glue to hold the mini cookie to the Oreo Cookie.
  10. -Add a small dot of white icing as the eye on the mini nutter butter cookie.
  11. -Place a tiny orange icing dot (eye ball) in the center of the white dot (eye).
  12. -Add three tiny yellow icing dots, touching each other, for the nose.
  13. -Add a red icing for the waddle.
  14. -Allow to dry for 5-10 hours.
  15. -Tie a bow around the candy stick.
Icing Directions:
  1. -Combine all ingredients in a mixing bowl mixing on medium speed for 4 minutes. (except your food coloring)
  2. -If icing is not stiff enough add ¼ C powder sugar.
  3. - Spoon the icing into a bowl (#1). Take out 4 TBSP of icing add several drops of orange gel food coloring. Mix well!
  4. - Spoon the icing into a bowl (#2). Take out 4 TBSP of icing add several drops of yellow gel food coloring. Mix well!
  5. -Add several drops of red gel food coloring in a bowl (#3) of 4 TBSP of icing. Stir well to mix the color.
  6. -Keep the rest of the icing as white.
  7. -Spoon the different colors of the icing into Individual pastry bags with a #5 tips.
  8. -Twist the open end of the pastry bag to force the icing to the tip.
3.4.3177

This is also part of our 6 “Instant” Thanksgiving Themed Treats ideas and you can see all 6 ideas in this video here and more information on our Thanksgiving Page here.

Look for more easy and frugal ideas in our DIY Gallery and our Recipe Gallery

Filed Under: Recipes, Thanksgiving

Previous Post: « Take Back Your Finances #44: Kitchen Overhaul
Next Post: 30 Great Thanksgiving Books To Share With Your Kids (Includes Free Printable List To Take To The Library) »

Reader Interactions

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Rate this recipe:  

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Primary Sidebar

  • Email
  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • Pinterest
  • RSS
  • Twitter

Read About Our New Book

Read About Our New Book

Check Our Our Podcast!

Check Our Our Podcast!

Get a Deal on Our Book Now!

Looking for Inspiration?







Our Most Popular Articles

Our Most Popular Articles

Copyright © 2022 · The Thrifty Couple · Please check out our Privacy Policy and our Disclosure Policy.